Fed Rate Raising Talk Raising False Fears

This article was originally published on on June 10th at 1:30pm EDT

Everyone seems pretty concerned about when the Fed is going to “raise rates,” and what that will mean for the stock and bond markets. Determining what the stock and bond markets will do seems to be skipping a step—how about first figuring out what impact a Fed rate hike will have on interest rates?

This may seem a ridiculous and rhetorical question, given that the Fed will be raising rates, but keep in mind that with QE over, the Fed has little control over what happens to the long end of the curve. What the Fed will be raising, when they do finally “raise rates,” will be the Federal Funds rate—the overnight rate at which banks lend money to each other. This rate has been zero (0-0.25%) for over six years.

But What About Quantitative Easing? QE is Over, and Now Rates Should Go Up

Janet Yellen and the Federal Reserve ended Quantitative Easing almost eight months ago in October of 2014—meaning, the Fed stopped altogether its purchase of Treasury Bonds and Mortgage Backed Securities. And what was the market’s immediate response?

Yields on long-dated Treasury Bonds (as represented above by the 30-year Treasury) sunk by nearly a full percent in the four months following the culmination of QE. Seems remarkably counterintuitive…

So what happened?

I don’t think the answer has anything to do with the rates being paid on that paper. Rather, it has to do with what happened to the US Dollar as a result of the Fed’s guidance. Removal of QE and the coincident interpretation of fewer dollars in circulation, coupled with the Fed’s signal of US economic strength, resulted in a strengthening US Dollar.

To reiterate an argument we made in our “Themes to Watch in 2015” piece, a strong or strengthening dollar makes US Treasury Bonds a perfect hedge for foreign buyers concerned about their own currencies weakening. And the Fed raising short-term rates will only serve to further strengthen the USD against the currencies of foreign countries (where they are still in the process of easing). Our yield curve ought to flatten.

So why would I want to expose myself to the interest rate risk inherent with a 30-year Treasury Bond instead of buying the 10-year? That likely depends on how long I want to hedge my currency risk.

Remember, if my currency is losing value against the USD—say 10% annually (conservative for just about any country in Latin America or Asia)—a portfolio of US Treasury Bonds is an excellent investment, if not just a hedge against inflation. If my currency is losing 20% annually against the dollar, it’s a no brainer to load up.

Let’s take a look at the recent rate spike on a longer term scale—a spike that I contend was not necessarily in anticipation of a Fed move, but profit taking among bond investors (both of the domestic and international variety) followed by short covering, all the way up to a strong resistance level for the 10-year Treasury.

Something to pay attention to is how various assets have responded to the recent spike higher in rates. Below you can see that some of the typically most interest-rate-sensitive asset classes—REITs (VNQ), Master Limited Partnerships (AMJ), Long-dated Treasury Bonds (TLT), and Utilities (IDU)—haven’t been nearly as impacted as you might think by a 30% spike in rates.

Are the somewhat subdued moves in these asset classes telling us that rates moving appreciably higher from here is unlikely?

I think many are misunderstanding the potential impact of the Fed “raising rates.” And I think it’s possible, once again, that fears of rising rates are misplaced. I think the asset classes depicted above are, actually, the place to be right now.

Is the idea that long-term rates are certainly going to move higher from here a bogeyman? I think so. And positioning one’s portfolio out of fear of the bogeyman could be a costly mistake….

For different perspectives on the same subject, see Jared Dillian’s reasoning for why rates could be headed higher (here), or J.C. Parets’ argument in favor of lower rates (here).

Have a question? Call or email us!

Adam B. Scott
Argyle Capital Partners, LLC
10100 Santa Monica Blvd, #300
Los Angeles, CA 90067
(310) 772-2201 – Main

Adam Scott’s profile on RealMoney can be found here.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *